NC Death Penalty – 2011 Year in Review

January 5, 2012

Quick Facts

  • Executions: 0
  • Persons removed from death row for other reasons: 3
  • New death sentences: 3
  • Capital trials not resulting in death: 11

In Detail

  • Persons Removed from Death Row

> Isaac Stroud (Durham) – In February, Isaac Stroud was declared incompetent to be executed and re-sentenced to life.

> John Fleming (Northampton) – This fall, John Fleming died of natural causes at the age of 83.  Fleming was first sent to death row at the age of 70.

> David “Bo” Williams (Bertie) – David Williams died of natural causes at the age of 46.  He had been on death row since 1996.

  • New Death Sentences

> Tony Summers (Guilford) – Tony Summers was convicted of stabbing Lavell Williams and assaulting her two children.

> Danny Hembree (Gaston) – Danny Hembree was convicted of smothering Heather Catterton.

> William Robinson (Stanly) – William Robinson was convicted of shooting Keith Crump and injuring another man.

  • Capital Trials Not Resulting in Death

> Michael Mead (Gaston) – Michael Mead was found not guilty of killing his pregnant fiancée and setting her house on fire.  The defense presented evidence that Mead was 50 miles away when the crime occurred.

> Al Bellamy (Iredell/Gaston) – A mistrial was declared when it was revealed during the guilt-or-innocence phase of Al Bellamy’s trial that prosecutors failed to disclose over 1700 pages of evidence to the defense.  If the State elects to try Bellamy again, it will be prohibited from seeking the death penalty.

> Robert Stewart (Moore) – Robert Stewart was convicted of second-degree murder after opening fire in a nursing home and killing eight people.  The cumulative sentence was at least 141 years in prison.

> Brandon Gross (Buncombe) – Brandon Gross was convicted of second degree murder, robbery, and burglary for beating a man to death in his home.  He will serve at least 43 years in prison.

> Shelton Mills (Pitt) – Shelton Mills was sentenced to life without the possibility of parole after being convicted of killing his ex-girlfriend and her new boyfriend.

> Danny Thomas (Columbus) –Danny Thomas, previously convicted of murder in another county was sentenced to life without the possibility of parole for four additional killings.

> Joshua Stepp (Wake) – Joshua Stepp was sentenced to life without the possibility of parole for the sexual assault and beating death of his ten month-old stepdaughter.

> Larry Robinson (Robeson) – Larry Robinson killed two men and injured a third in an ambush-style assault, and was sentenced to life without parole.

> Melba Slaydon (Randolph) – During jury selection, Melba Slaydon accepted a plea to life without parole in the killing of her husband.

> Dennis Mills (Alamance) – During jury selection, Dennis Mills accepted a plea to life without parole for shooting two men to death in their home.  Mills had previously been convicted of another homicide.

> James Richardson (Pitt) – After James Richardson was convicted of killing two men in a drive-by shooting, prosecutors dropped their request for the death penalty.


North Carolina’s Death Row 2012

January 4, 2012

As of January 1, 2012, North Carolina’s death row was home to 154 men and 4 women.  Of these, 63 were white and 95 were minorities.  Source here.

DOC  #

Last Name

First Name

County

1

0234897

Laws Wayne A. Davidson

2

0207779

Jennings Patricia W. Wilson

3

0288088

Moore Blanche T. Forsyth

4

0265106

McCollum Henry L. Cumberland

5

0351933

Rose Clinton R. Rockingham

6

0100579

Davis Edward E. Buncombe

7

0353186

Rouse Kenneth B. Randolph

8

0339314

Reeves Michael M. Craven

9

0347839

Robinson Eddie C. Bladen

10

0264009

McCarver Ernest P. Cabarrus

11

0294214

Moseley Carl Forsyth

12

0039561

Bowie Nathan Catawba

13

0039569

Bowie William Catawba

14

0057308

Burkes Rayford L. Iredell

15

0058316

Burr John Alamance

16

0104984

Decastro Eugene Johnston

17

0156518

Gregory Warren Pitt

18

0251740

Lynch David Gaston

19

0021418

Barrett Jeffrey Northampton

20

0030124

Best Norfolk Columbus

21

0063592

Campbell James Rowan

22

0141374

Garner Daniel Robeson

23

0099090

Daughtry Johnny R. Johnston

24

0054499

Buckner George C. Gaston

25

0441726

Williams James E. Randolph

26

0343075

Richardson Martin A. Union

27

0012311

Atkins Randy L. Buncombe

28

0017060

Ball Terry L. Beaufort

29

0071799

Chambers Frank J. Rowan

30

0020590

Barnes William L. Rowan

31

0221506

Kandies Jeffrey Randolph

32

0453231

Wooten Vincent M. Pitt

33

0120038

Elliott John R. Davidson

34

0082151

Cole Wade L. Camden

35

0348505

Robinson Marcus Cumberland

36

0166056

Harden Alden Mecklenburg

37

0156529

Gregory William Davie

38

0438643

Wilkinson Phillip Cumberland

39

0143501

Geddie Malcolm Johnston

40

0095279

Cummings Daniel Brunswick

41

0443375

Williams Marvin E. Wayne

42

0085045

Connor Jerry W. Gates

43

0404386

Thomas James E. Wake

44

0368820

Sidden Tony M. Alexander

45

0036850

Bond Charles P. Bertie

46

0233526

Larry Thomas M. Forsyth

47

0497100

Woods Darrell C. Forsyth

48

0492102

Richardson Timothy Nash

49

0061528

Cagle Richard Cumberland

50

0180479

Herring William Wake

51

0487180

Warren Leslie Buncombe

52

0393145

Strickland Darrell Union

53

0511057

Hill Jerry Dale Harnett

54

0511998

East Keith B. Surry

55

0275678

McNeil John D. Cumberland

56

0414853

Tyler Stacey A. Hertford

57

0388922

Stephens Davy G. Johnston

58

0413011

Tucker Russell Forsyth

59

0495163

Neal Kenneth Rockingham

60

0499258

Murillo Eric F. Richmond

61

0238344

LeGrande Guy T. Stanly

62

0376917

Smith Jamie L. Buncombe

63

0246186

Locklear Robbie D. Robeson

64

0471315

Billings Archie L. Caswell

65

0506556

Guevara Angel Johnston

66

0405380

Thomas Walic C. Guilford

67

0037215

Bonnett Shawn D. Martin

68

0510234

Davis James F. Buncombe

69

0434355

White Melvin L. Craven

70

0412440

Trull Gary A. Randolph

71

0320825

Peterson Lawrence E. Richmond

72

0422350

Wallace Henry L. Mecklenburg

73

0539901

Taylor Terrence Lenoir

74

0311966

Parker Johnny S. Sampson

75

0176701

Hedgepath Rowland Halifax

76

0255136

Mann Leroy Wake

77

0585797

Davis Phillip Buncombe

78

0352024

Roseboro Christopher Gaston

79

0033802

Blakeney Roger Union

80

0488288

Mitchell Marcos Wake

81

0095361

Cummings Jerry Robeson

82

0134151

Fowler Elrico Mecklenburg

83

0552017

Moses Erroll Forsyth

84

0043529

Braxton Michael Halifax

85

0597164

Lawrence Jimmie Harnett

86

0599379

Williams John Wake

87

0137368

Frogg Danny Forsyth

88

0587681

Holman Allen Wake

89

0158506

Grooms Timmy Scotland

90

0590940

Golphin Tilmon Cumberland

91

0542024

Hyde Johnny Onslow

92

0388640

Steen Patrick Mecklenburg

93

0584095

Brewington Robert Harnett

94

0472274

Taylor Rodney New Hanover

95

0226428

King James Guilford

96

0280127

Meyer Jeffery Cumberland

97

0330166

Prevatte Ted Stanly

98

0515143

Thibodeaux Raymond Forsyth

99

0580028

May Lyle Buncombe

100

0311386

Parker Carlette Wake

101

0125241

Fair Nathaniel Wake

102

0542384

Call Eric Ashe

103

0654009

Wiley Keith New Hanover

104

0654093

Anthony William Gaston

105

0206197

Jaynes James Polk

106

0291861

Morgan James Buncombe

107

0491889

Barden Iziah Sampson

108

0130628

Fletcher Andre L. Rutherford

109

0199877

Hyatt Terry A. Buncombe

110

0561692

Hooks Cerron T. Forsyth

111

0349019

Robinson Terry L. Wilson

112

0688223

Squires Mark L. Pitt

113

0626944

Walters Christina Cumberland

114

0051026

Brown Paul A. Wayne

115

0434845

White Timothy L. Forsyth

116

0189289

Holmes Michael D. Johnston

117

0217326

Jones, Sr. Marcus Douglas Onslow

118

0486636

Carter Shan E. New Hanover

119

0702066

Garcia Fernando L. Wake

120

0561943

Haselden Jim E. Stokes

121

0428143

Watts James Hollis Davidson

122

0592464

Bell Bryan Christopher Onslow

123

0742512

Miller Clifford Ray Onslow

124

0379083

Smith Reche Washington

125

0064125

Campbell Terrance Pender

126

0765397

Smith Wesley Toby Rowan

127

0612123

Augustine Quintel Brunswick

128

0406487

Thompson John Henry Guilford

129

0290634

Moore
(Al-Bayyinah)
Terry
(Jathiyah)
Davie

130

0113234

Duke Jeffrey Neal Gaston

131

0133102

Forte Linwood Earl Wayne

132

0005091

Allen Scott D. Montgomery

133

0120236

Elliott Terrance R. Moore

134

0509565

Hurst Jason Wayne Randolph

135

0014016

Badgett John Scott Randolph

136

0523493

Cummings Paul Dewayne New Hanover

137

0801680

Polke Alexander C. Randolph

138

0150949

Goss Christopher Ashe

139

0667195

Lane Eric Glenn Wayne

140

0762634

Taylor Eddie Larmar Harnett

141

0526698

Raines William H. Henderson

142

0940436

Murrell Jeremy Dushane Forsyth

143

0831753

Maness Darrell W. Brunswick

144

0775602

Garcell Ryan G. Rutherford

145

0900281

Wilkerson George Thomas Randolph

146

0441044

Williams Eugene Johnny Cumberland

147

1025501

Waring Byron Lamar Wake

148

0604251

Phillips Mario Moore

149

0846840

Little James R. Forsyth

150

0366770

Sherrill Michael Mecklenburg

151

0796623

Bacote Jamaal H. Johnston

152

1033115

Ryan Michael Patrick Gaston

153

0972488

Ramseur Andrew Darrin Iredell

154

1062462

Buckner Stephen McDowell

155

0172431

Hartford Timothy, Jr. Forsyth

156

0395658

Summers Tony Savalis Guilford

157

0177668

Hembree Danny Robbie, Jr. Gaston

158

0694689

Robinson William E. Stanly

Perdue Vetoes Racial Justice Act Repeal; Legislature Called Back to Raleigh

December 22, 2011

Governor Beverly Perdue issued her veto of the Racial Justice Act repeal bill on December 14th.  Her veto will stand, and the RJA will be preserved, unless both chambers of the General Assembly vote to override.  The legislature will return to session for a single day – January 4th – to decide the issue.  Under North Carolina law, the override will not succeed unless 3/5ths of present and voting members of each chamber vote in support.


Larry Robinson Sentenced to Life Without Parole

December 22, 2011

The last capital trial of 2011 ended in a life sentence yesterday.

Larry Bonnell Shawn Robinson was sentenced to life without the possibility of parole by a Robeson County jury after less than 30 minutes of deliberation.  The same jury previously found Robinson guilty of one count of first-degree murder, one count of second-degree murder, and one count of assault with a deadly weapon inflicting serious injury for his role in a 2007 shooting that left two men dead and a third injured.


William Robinson Sentenced to Death

December 9, 2011

A Stanly County jury has sentenced William Eugene Robinson to death for the 2006 murder of Kevin Devon Crump.


NC Capital Trial Update 12-7-11

December 7, 2011

In Stanly County, William Eugene Robinson has been convicted of first-degree murder and other related charges in the death of Keith Crump.  The trial will now proceed to the sentencing phase, at which the jury must decide whether Robinson should be sentenced to life without the possibility of parole, or to death.

DW remains unable to find any information in the media about the Robeson County trial of Larry Bonnell Shawn Robinson.  DW notes that Mr. Robinson is not in the custody of the Department of Correction at this time.

No additional capital trials are scheduled in North Carolina for the remainder of this calendar year.


Save the Racial Justice Act

December 7, 2011

It has been a little over a week since the North Carolina General Assembly voted to repeal the Racial Justice Act, a landmark piece of legislation which enabled death row inmates to challenge their sentences by showing patterns of racial discrimination in the jurisdictions where they were tried.

Since then, Republican lawmakers have been accused of ignoring undisputed evidence of racial bias in the administration of the death penalty and abusing the legislative system to sneak through legislation without public oversight.

Groups including the NC-NAACP have called on Governor Beverly Perdue to veto the bill, but there has been no word from her office as of this writing.  Under North Carolina law, Governor Perdue has 30 days to issue a veto.  The Governor has indicated that she will make her decision next week.

  • We all deserve the truth

Defendants have alleged a pervasive pattern of racial discrimination, both in jury selection and in decisions about which cases deserve the death penalty.  It has been over a year since motions were filed presenting evidence to support these claims.  Since August of 2010, the ball has been in the State’s court, but prosecutors haven’t even attempted to prove that something other than race is involved.

Rather than confront the issue head on, prosecutors have tried to delay the courts.  After months of ill-founded constitutional challenges and even an attempt to prevent a black judge from presiding over the matter, the first real test of the Racial Justice Act was scheduled to begin next month.  Just in time, conservative lawmakers swooped in to repeal the Racial Justice Act.

Prosecutors and lawmakers have nothing to fear but the truth being heard.  If the claims made under the Racial Justice Act are frivolous, no court will hesitate to throw them out.  Prosecutors claim that the RJA has placed a moratorium on the death penalty, when the reality is that the only thing preventing these cases from moving forward is prosecutors’ sandbagging of the judicial process.

  • The RJA is not a get out of jail free card

Prosecutors and conservative lawmakers have circulated the false rumor that a successful Racial Justice Act claim could result in death row inmates being immediately released from prison.  Never mind that the statute explicitly says that the only relief available is a sentence of life without the possibility of parole.

It is constitutional for a death sentence to be converted to life without parole, even if the option of life without parole was not available at the time of the original trial.  This is exactly what happens when a death row inmate is granted clemency by the governor.  [For inmates sentenced prior to 1994, the jury did not have the option of life without the possibility of parole.]

Any inmate who meets the high bar of proving his claim under the Racial Justice Act will be re-sentenced to life without the possibility of parole.  He will be punished, for the rest of his life, for the acts he committed, and not for the acts or omissions of anyone else.  Just as justice has always intended.

Call Governor Perdue today and urge her to veto the repeal of the Racial Justice Act.  The numbers for her office are (800) 662-7952 and (919) 733-2391.  People of Faith Against the Death Penalty have a petition you can sign online, or you can e-mail the Governor yourself at this address

Media roundup

ACLU blog

Colorlines

The Daily Tarheel

Independent Weekly

Mother Jones

ThinkProgress


Racial Justice Media Roundup

November 28, 2011

The North Carolina Senate is meeting today in an unusual short session.  One issue on the table – and the chopping block – is the Racial Justice Act.  The Conference of District Attorneys (in a letter the  NAACP contends is inaccurate and misleading) has urged legislators to effectively repeal the landmark bill.  Defense attorneys have submitted a letter of their own, urging the General Assembly to preserve inmates’ right to present evidence of racial bias in the administration of the death penalty.

More to come as this story develops.

Local papers:

Asheville Citizen-Times: Racial Justice Act ‘Fix’ Would in Essence End It

Fayetteville Observer: Prosecutors See Danger in Sentence Reviews

Wilmington Star-News: Effort to Repeal Racial Justice Act Would Tip the Scales the Wrong Way

Winston-Salem Journal: District Attorneys Call for End to Racial Justice Act

Letters to the Editor/Op-Eds/Blog Posts:

District Attorneys v. The Law by James Coleman (Duke law professor)

Racial Justice Act is Necessary by Hannah Autry

Nothing New in Death Row Debate by Scott Mooneyham

Our Judicial System Should be Color Blind by George Burazer

Racial Justice Act Should be Defended by Cecil Bothwell (Asheville city councilman)

In Defense of NC’s Racial Justice Act by scharrison @ BlueNC

Detecting Bias in Death Penalty Cases by Frank Baumgartner (UNC political science professor)


Hembree Sentenced to Death; Two Robinson Trials Continue

November 21, 2011

In Gaston County, Danny Hembree was sentenced to death for the murder of Heather Catterton.  Although the victim’s family supported the death penalty, her father recognized, “This was a no-win situation. They’ve lost a son. We’ve lost a daughter.”

The Robeson County trial of Larry Robinson continues without media coverage.

The State is presenting evidence in the Stanly County trial of William Robinson.  Robinson is accused of shooting a man during a 2006 robbery.


State Moves to Recuse Black Judge from Racial Justice Act Motions

November 10, 2011

In Cumberland County today, prosecutors are arguing that Gregory Weeks, the Senior Resident Superior Court Judge for the county, should be disqualified from hearing claims under the Racial Justice Act.  Weeks is a 23-year veteran of the bench – who also happens to be African-American.  Of course, prosecutors aren’t saying that they want Weeks off the case because he’s black.  They claim that Weeks should recuse himself because he has presided over some of the death penalty trials in question, and therefore might be a witness.  If this were the State’s true motivation, it seems that they would also have moved to recuse Judge William Wood, who is presiding over Racial Justice Act claims in Forsyth County.  Wood, who is white, has also been the trial judge in a death penalty case affected by the RJA.

Duke University law professor Jim Coleman says, “It looks like they’re trying to get rid of an African-American judge and have the case heard by someone who likely would not be African-American…They’re accused of manipulating the jury on the basis of race. It’s ironic that they would do something that looks like they’re trying to … manipulate the judge who would hear the case [for the same reason].”

The State made its motion on the eve of the first real test of the RJA, a hearing that was to take place before Judge Weeks on November 14th.  That hearing may now be delayed.  The State’s motion is highly unusual and perhaps unprecedented.  Attorney Ken Rose says, “I’ve been doing this 30 years. I’ve never seen a judge recused for that reason.”  Judge Weeks has retained his own lawyer, Fred Webb, to argue that it is inappropriate to call a judge as a witness under these circumstances.

Media here, here, here, and here.


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.